In Park Lake III, LLC v. Commissioner, T.C. Memo. 2026-122 (11/19/26), here (also can be viewed in the docket entries here), Judge Lauber rejects the SCE bullshit shelter’s Hail Mary pass via the § 6751(b) written supervisor approval requirement. Judge Lauber provides a good and relatively succinct discussion of key aspects of § 6751(b) but really plows no new ground (hence it is not a T.C. opinion). (Of course, this involved a tax year prior to the § 6751(b) Regulations, so may be important only for older cases.)
I asked ChatGPT Plus: “Please create a limerick-type poem on the contents of the Tax Court case.” You can see the response here, but I copy and paste it:
The Park Lake Penalty Predicament
Inspired by Park Lake III, LLC v. Commissioner, T.C. Memo. 2026-122 (Nov. 19, 2026)
There once was a firm called Park Lake,
With a deduction of rather large stake.
Fourteen million they claimed,
But the Service exclaimed,
“That’s a bit more than we think you should take!”An agent named Neighbors took aim,
At penalties tied to the claim.
His boss, Mr. Burris,
Signed off without worries,
And the Court found no fault in the game.Park Lake said, “But where's the appraisal?
Doesn't that call for some careful perusal?”
Judge Lauber replied,
“The law's satisfied—
A signature needs no exegesis or dazzle!”The taxpayers argued once more,
“That approval came from the wrong door!”
But the Judge said, “The or
Is what Congress wrote for—
Your objections persuade me no more.”So the lesson of Park Lake is plain:
A supervisor's signature may reign.
Though the merits await,
On approval's debate,
The Service has carried the day.The legal punchline: Section 6751(b) requires written supervisory approval, not proof of thoughtful supervisory deliberation. As Judge Lauber emphasized, Congress required approval, not explanation.
No comments:
Post a Comment
Comments are moderated. Jack Townsend will review and approve comments only to make sure the comments are appropriate. Although comments can be made anonymously, please identify yourself (either by real name or pseudonymn) so that, over a few comments, readers will be able to better judge whether to read the comments and respond to the comments.