This article popped up from a Google alert this morning. Andrew Mark Miller, Little-known IRS program could be unfairly crushing landowners, according to alarming study and whistleblower (Fox News 11/17/26), here. The article is the typical Fox News bullshit that readers of this blog should easily recognize as bullshit. But then Fox News believers will claim to think otherwise and are happy to see the IRS demonized even if it is fake news.
The article discusses a report by Infinity Advisory Services, here. The report, titled Predetermination in the Federal Conservation Easement Campaign (September 2026), is here. Miller’s Fox News article describes the report as follows (with my bold-facing to point to problems with the report):
The study makes the case that the pattern across different properties, tax years and reviewers points to a process designed to reach a predetermined answer, which effectively wiped out the value underpinning taxpayers’ conservation deductions rather than fairly evaluating each property.
* * * *
"This report examines a single question," the study's authors explain in the executive summary. "We ask whether the government's valuation position in conservation easement matters was settled as a matter of policy before it was tested against the facts of individual properties. The record we have assembled to date is consistent with that view, and in our judgment the pattern in the data is difficult to explain on another basis."
The actual report says (p. 3, 6):
We are careful about what this report does and does not establish. Nothing here demonstrates that any individual taxpayer appraisal was correct or incorrect. Those appraisals were not examined, and each matter deserves its own analysis. What the record does support, including the uniform 97% reduction in value, is that the government’s figures were not developed in accordance with the standards the reports themselves invoke. The Service's August 2026 announcement recognized part of the problem when it ended uniform settlement terms. That change did not turn on any single matter. Case specific resolution, however, requires case specific valuation, and on this record and in this report that work has not yet been done.
* * * *
We believe that the record perhaps details that an analytic position was developed within the government before the examination program was built; enforcement action timed to external advocacy rather than to the development of case evidence; categorical public characterization of the outcome before adjudication; constraints on the government's own valuation professionals that foreclose the approaches capable of supporting a higher value; and a settlement schedule priced from a sample the government itself assembled.
Then, realizing that the results of actual valuations tested in the crucible of litigation are not consistent with its claims (in that the results are more consistent with IRS valuations actually litigated), the report says (p. 5): “nothing in this report is offered as a criticism of the expert work the Tax Court considered.”
Notice fuzz words such as “believe” and “perhaps;” and the report does not and cannot say that either the taxpayer’s or the IRS’s valuations were correct or incorrect.
All of which is to prove the truth of the aphorism: “There are lies, damned lies, and statistics” See Wikipedia entry, “Lies, Damned Lies, and Statistics” (last edited 10/4/26 and viewed 11/18/26), here (reporting that Twain attributed the saying to Benjamin Disreali, although not found in his extant works).
The report then implies (pp. 11-14) that the IRS erred in rejecting the shelters’ “before” contribution appraisals but accepting the shelters’ “after” contribution values. Well, duh. The abuse in the shelters is in the before valuations; the shelter has little incentive to misstate the after valuations by materially claiming a lower value (the reported after valuations were pretty low anyway and, although a lower after value would increase the deduction, lower values would draw more attention). So, the IRS just conserved its limited resources by accepting the shelter’s reported after valuations in the audit process. In litigation, however, testimony comes in as to the after valuation with the real fight over the before valuation.
I am not claiming that the statistics reported in the report or the Fox News article are not correct. I am just contesting the inferences of IRS misconduct they want readers to draw. When considered in context, the inferences I draw and I think reasonably knowledgeable tax audit and litigation practitioners should draw are that the IRS is managing its resources in the best interests of the American people in dealing with abuses by those promoting and claiming deductions based on bullshit valuations.
In my opinion, the more likely reason that the IRS valuations were a small percentage of the valuations claimed on the tax returns is that the valuations claimed on the tax returns were driven by the deductions the shelters needed to market the shelters. That need alone required valuations multiples over the real values for abusive (aka bullshit) SCE shelters. (There may have been SCE shelters that used real defensible valuations; but that is not evidenced in the mainstream of litigated cases.) Hence, when the IRS audits the shelters’ claims, the resulting real values are a mere fraction of what the shelters claimed on the returns. Nothing surprising there.
BTW, as I have often noted in this blog, valuations require credible experts. The shelters valuations offered in return reporting and then at trial are not credible—at least in the cases litigated to date.
I challenge the author and his sources and SCE shelters generally to seek baseball arbitration with the IRS. If the shelters’ valuations are bullshit, they will get the same result as litigation (they lose and IRS wins) at far less cost and commotion. But they won’t get the delay that litigation offers them (in truth, delay seems to be the goal of much bullshit tax litigation).
Moreover, as I have noted, one way to discourage the bullshit litigation is to impose a penalty on litigated valuations in the same way the § 6662(h) applies to gross valuation misstatements on the return if the valuation asserted at trial if either the shelter/taxpayer or the IRS misses benchmarks for the penalty. Congress should act.
Another way is to put parties in litigation on notice that the Court will use the tools it already has to encourage the parties and their experts to get real in the valuations they promote in litigation. See Tax Court Rejects a Bullshit Tax Shelter False Valuation Claim with Warning of Sanctions for Taxpayers, their Counsel, and Expert Witness Proffering the Bullshit (7/16/25; 9/10/25), here.
No comments:
Post a Comment
Comments are moderated. Jack Townsend will review and approve comments only to make sure the comments are appropriate. Although comments can be made anonymously, please identify yourself (either by real name or pseudonymn) so that, over a few comments, readers will be able to better judge whether to read the comments and respond to the comments.